How is China capitalist? Social ownership is the principal aspect of their economy, and the working class controls the state. In line with classical Marxist economics, underdeveloped industry is marketized, while developed, centralized industry is planned. Capitalism would imply capitalists are in control and that the economy is dominated by private ownership, but that’s the opposite of how China actually operates.
Yeah it’s all down to who owns things. Any form of hierarchy can oppress, some make it harder by including more of the would-be oppressed in decision making.
That is because tankies are not leftists, they are authoritarian simps larping as leftists.
I don’t think it makes sense to claim Marxists aren’t left, and to reduce Marxism to just “authoritarian simps.”
Left includes the authoritarian left, as much as we’d rather them go away.
Fair. But I would not classify Russian imperialism nor modern CCP capitalism, to be left at all.
How is China capitalist? Social ownership is the principal aspect of their economy, and the working class controls the state. In line with classical Marxist economics, underdeveloped industry is marketized, while developed, centralized industry is planned. Capitalism would imply capitalists are in control and that the economy is dominated by private ownership, but that’s the opposite of how China actually operates.
Fair
Yeah it’s all down to who owns things. Any form of hierarchy can oppress, some make it harder by including more of the would-be oppressed in decision making.